Shearing the Oscars: Best Picture

The nominations for the 82nd annual Academy Awards were announced this past week and, if you care about the Oscars at all, you likely knew already that they were to be expanding their Best Picture category from five to ten slots. It may have been a thinly veiled attempt to ensure the telecast audience grows this year by embracing a wider array of films but did it work? My guess, based on the support the films reached in other categories and the feelings I'm getting in my stomach, I would venture that had the Academy stuck with five nominees, they would look a little something like this:

AVATAR
THE HURT LOCKER
INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS
PRECIOUS
UP IN THE AIR

I would have been satisfied with that, even with AVATAR being included. Thanks to the new rules though, the following films get to bask in Oscar glory as well:

THE BLIND SIDE
DISTRICT 9
AN EDUCATION
A SERIOUS MAN
UP

All, save for one, which I will allow you to figure out all by yourself, are well deserving. So, it would appear, that Oscar did good so far and their future bodes well. I'm still back and forth on the move though. On the one hand, I feel that honouring ten films better encompasses all genres and audiences. On the other, I feel it cheapens the recognition itself. While I am torn on this point, I am decisively upset with the media for how they've handled the whole thing. The Academy goes out of its way to reach a wider audience and honour more films and what do you do? You whittle the list down to a mere two entries, suggesting this biblical David vs. Goliath cage match between THE HURT LOCKER and AVATAR, as though none of the other films stand any chance. I understand that frontrunners exist but to be fair, INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS has eight nominations in total, only one less than the big two. UP IN THE AIR has already won plenty of top prizes during awards season too. Even PRECIOUS, whose buzz died off long ago, still has Oprah behind it. If she can get a president elected, she can get a measly, little Oscar.

And so, in the interest of actually considering all ten nominated films instead of writing them off immediately after they were announced, Black Sheep will break down the nominations for Best Picture, one by one, beginning with ...

AVATAR

Do I believe AVATAR has an excellent chance of winning Best Picture? Yes, it does. Do I believe it should win? Of course not. The entire world has been swept up in the incredible spell AVATAR has cast on filmgoing audiences. Do I believe it warrants its nomination? Yes, I do. Any film that wows and inspires as many people as this one has, deserves to honoured as one of the best pictures of the year. An exciting adventure doesn't always make for an incredible film though. Director James Cameron's screenplay is unoriginal and obvious and the acting is uneven at best. Sure, I had a good time watching AVATAR but nothing other than that has stayed with me. A Best Picture winner should be timeless.

THE BLIND SIDE

I swore I would never see this movie when I first saw the preview and I finally had to cave last weekend because it was becoming pretty clear that Sandra Bullock was going to score a Best Actress nomination for her work in it. She did just that and, in another beguiling sign that she has a very good shot at winning that award, she also inspired enough love to elevate the film itself into the Best Picture race. Clearly, I had very low expectations for THE BLIND SIDE but I was pleasantly surprised. By that, I mean, it was alright. Alright should not be nominated for Best Picture, let alone win, and, in this case, it won't.

DISTRICT 9

I don't think DISTRICT 9 has any genuine chance of winning this award but the fact that it's here speaks to how much unexpected impact it had on those who saw it, including myself. (DISTRICT 9 is nominated for Best Picture at Black Sheep's Mouton d'Or Awards this year as well.) The Academy also showered the film with love for its elaborate and imaginative screenplay as well as its very real visual effects and intense editing style. Stealing an editing slot from bigger fish, UP IN THE AIR, suggests that its chances are stronger than I think they are but if a piece of science-fiction is going to win this year, it will be for bluer aliens than these.

AN EDUCATION

As AN EDUCATION too earned a Mouton d'Or nomination for Best Picture this year, it is clearly a favorite of mine and I am thrilled to see it make the final cut, alongside the brilliant Nick Hornby screenplay and the breathtaking performance by Carey Mulligan. This film has a much better chance of winning overseas at the BAFTA's though than in Hollywood. It is one of the nominated films that stands a good chance to see its box office receipts increase now but that is only because it has not been seen by many at all. (It has earned less than all of the other nominated films in this category.) It's lack of exposure will ultimately cripple it.

THE HURT LOCKER

This Kathryn Bigelow picture has only made a few million dollars more than AN EDUCATION but has been lauded as the Best Picture of the year by critics almost universally. And now that it is available to rent, interest in the film has, uh, exploded, if you will. Critical darlings don't always take the big prize and God knows war-themed pictures have struggled hard for years now but THE HURT LOCKER has the potential to transcend that. It will reach an audience now that it may never have without this recognition and that audience will be shaken by its overpowering tension. They won't know what hit them and if the HURT LOCKER Oscar campaign doesn't trip any major wires before the big night, the rest of the nominees won't know what hit them either.

Black Sheep's breakdown of the Best Picture nominees continues tomorrow with INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS, PRECIOUS, A SERIOUS MAN, UP and UP IN THE AIR.

In the meantime, what do you think? Is it really just a race between AVATAR and THE HURT LOCKER? If it is, was it worth expanding the list to begin with? Black Sheep wants to know what you think!