Tuesday, December 13, 2011

CARNAGE


CARNAGE 
Written by Yasmina Reza and Roman Polanski
Directed by Roman Polanski
Starring Jodie Foster, Kate Winslet, Christoph Waltz and John C. Reilly

Penelope Longstreet: Why can’t things be easier? Why does everything have to be so exhausting?

There are some plays that seem as though they could never be adapted for the screen and Yasmina Reza’s “God of Carnage” is certainly one of them. Although I have not myself seen it on stage, I can imagine its physical scope is quite limited as all the action takes place in one apartment over the course of a few hours. On stage, this can be riveting, as long as the conversation itself is sharp and insightful and as long as those partaking in said conversation give brilliant performances. On film, one location with the same four characters can be a static stand still. Fortunately for Reza, all involved in the film adaptation of her play, now called CARNAGE, are precisely the right people to keep things moving.

At the CARNAGE helm is infamous director, Roman Polanski, a man who has seen his own fair share of carnage in his life. Reza herself collaborated with Polanski on the screenplay so the fundamentals are firmly intact. Essentially, two couples meet to discuss an altercation that took place between their boys in a playground that resulted in one of the boys losing teeth. Things naturally don’t go as well as anyone had hoped. And who does Polanski amass to captivate us with their wit and humour? Four brilliant actors of course as the entire acting community seem to clamor to work with him. Jodie Foster and John C. Reilly play parents to the boy who lost his teeth while Kate Winslet and Christoph Waltz play parents to the boy who was armed with the stick - sorry, who was carrying the stick - that knocked out the teeth. I don’t know about you but I can think of way worse people to be stuck in a room with for ninety minutes.


These two couples, as portrayed by this amazingly talented and dynamic cast, start out as sensible, civilized adults who are doing what they all think is right according to societal standards given the situation at hand. After all, what matters most is the well being of their children and ensuring that they come out of this as positively as possible. It’s the fact that the children are involved though that makes their exercise so futile to begin with. Their children were in a fight and hurt each other. The natural impulse for these parents would be to protect their children no matter what. And so it is not at all surprising to watch as their facades slowly but surely fade away to reveal not only their anger over the current situation but also the deep seeded disgust that has been festering in all of them for as long as they’ve had to hold it in. And given how polite our Western society can be at times, I’d say they’ve been holding back for a very long time.


Polanski does everything he must in order to keep a picture that almost never leaves the living room feel like it is in constant motion. Much of that comes from the rapid unravelling of the characters themselves. Their descent is delicious making CARNAGE a truly stimulating experience. Still, I imagine that if these four people exhibited just as much passion on stage, the immediacy of it would make their madness that much more meaningful.

6 comments:

Mike Lippert said...

I'm a bit up and down on this. I read the script back during the summer and thought it was savae on the level of Who's Afraid of Virginia Wolfe or Closer. Then the trailers came which made it look like a comedy, something absent from the script. Then the mixed festival reviews came. I guess I'll just have to wait and see.

Candice Frederick said...

so glad you liked this. i wanted to see it on Broadway. i was also skeptical about it coming to the big screen, especially given its one location the entire time (works more often for stage than film).

Dan O. said...

Polanski's tremendous skill with creating dramatic tension ensures that we're in for a gripping as well as a very funny ride. It was also even better because of the leads here and just how they take these roles, and make them their own. Good review. Check out mine when you get the chance.

Black Sheep said...

Yeah, CARNAGE was loads of fun. I'm sure some will find it terribly tedious and pretty pretentious but I thought it was just sharp, enjoyable satire. Plus how can you argue with this cast?! You just want more, more, more!

Steve Sauve said...

I couldn't believe it was over so soon. I was captivated the entire time. The camera work kept us interested in that one room (though indeed we are taken elsewhere in and out of the apartment), the sound recording and dialog editing was excellent, the frequent cellphone interruptions served as miniature 'intermissions' and gave us a break from the almost continuous conversation. I was least convinced by Kate Winslet until she began her slide into drunkenness, but the others were never absent from their characters. And the music, though heard only at the beginning and end, was exactly right!

Phips said...

I loved this film.

The four main actors are awesome! This film is hilarious and so far sits as the best film Ive seen in 2012 (and I've seen some good ones)